Three Senators Ask the App Stores to Explain 135 Apps

  • Tech
  • November 19, 2026
  • 0 Comments

A thirteen-year-old account could see them. That is the finding at the center of three letters sent Tuesday to the chief executives of Apple, Google and Meta.

Sens. Ron Wyden, Ed Markey and Ben Ray Luján wrote separately to the three companies, arguing that their platforms have failed to stop applications that generate nonconsensual nude images. The letters cite research conducted in October that identified 135 such apps in Apple’s and Google’s stores that were visible to a test account registered as a thirteen-year-old. Apps removed after the research were still usable on devices where they had already been installed. Meta was asked to explain how advertising for such apps cleared its review.

The companies said the apps violate their policies. Apple and Google said the material is prohibited and that offending apps were removed. Meta said it had taken down the apps and banned the advertisers behind them.

Those responses are accurate and beside the point, which is why the letters were written.

The gap the senators describe is a structural one. Federal law now requires platforms to remove nonconsensual intimate images within 48 hours of a valid request from the person depicted, under legislation signed in 2025. That obligation attaches to the platform hosting the image. The applications in question do not host anything; they generate an image on the user’s device from a photograph the user supplies. Removing the picture does not remove the tool that made it.

Apple and Google sit in a different position from a social network. They review every app before it is listed, they take a commission on sales made inside it, and their guidelines prohibit sexually explicit material. A company that approves an app and collects a share of its revenue has a harder time arguing that the app’s behavior is none of its business, and plaintiffs’ lawyers have noticed.

Review at that scale is imperfect by design. Apple’s App Store processes thousands of submissions a week, and reviewers see a binary and a screenshot rather than the model behind them. Developers who intend to ship a prohibited tool have learned to submit a benign version and enable the rest after approval through a remote switch. The practice is old enough that platform guidelines name it.

Age gating compounds the problem. The test account in the research was thirteen, which is the minimum age most services allow. A tool that requires users to confirm they are eighteen is a speed bump, not a barrier, and the researchers found that many of the apps did not bother with one.

Markey has been writing this letter for three decades. He was the principal author of the children’s privacy law that governs how sites collect data from users under thirteen, and he has spent his career arguing that platforms should bear obligations that match their control. Wyden chairs the Senate Finance Committee, which has jurisdiction over trade and consumer protection and a history of examining app store fees. Luján sits on the commerce committee that oversees the Federal Trade Commission.

A letter is not a subpoena, and none of the three has introduced a bill that would change the outcome. Congress has considered app store liability proposals for years without passing one, and the companies know that the arithmetic of a divided chamber rarely moves. What a letter can do is build a record, and a record is what a state attorney general or a private plaintiff uses when the next case arrives.

The advertising question is the one Meta will find hardest. A company that sells placements against a keyword has a machine that decides which advertiser matches which query. If apps of this kind bought inventory, the machine matched them to something, and the categories it used are recorded. Meta’s answer, that the advertisers were banned, describes the remedy rather than the review.

For the app stores, the exposure is financial and reputational at once. A single lawsuit brought by a person whose image was used would test whether a 30% commission creates a duty of care. A state law banning such apps outright would test something else: whether a national platform must comply with fifty regulatory regimes.

None of this resolves quickly. The apps that were removed will reappear under new names, a pattern researchers have documented for three years. The developers operate across borders, incorporate where registration is cheap and market through channels the stores do not control.

What the letters establish is a date and a set of questions with the companies’ names attached. Apple, Google and Meta have each said the conduct is prohibited. The senators are asking why, if that is true, a thirteen-year-old could find 135 examples in an afternoon, and why the ones taken down kept working on the phones that already had them.

Related Posts

  • November 20, 2026
  • 12 views
Micron Has Sold 75% of Its 2027 Memory Output Before the Plant Opens

Micron Technology has committed 75% of the high bandwidth memory it expects to produce in 2027, a year for which most of that capacity has not been built. The company…

  • November 20, 2026
  • 12 views
Tesla Opens a Truck Charging Stop and Sketches a Car With No Pedals

A charging site beside a highway outside a Texas city is an odd place to begin a vehicle program. On Nov. 19 Tesla opened its first Semi charging station in…